Punishment, Putin-style

Putin has the strangest way of punishing the foreigners he perceives as enemies.

Obama signs the Magnitsky bill? Putin bans Americans from banning Russian orphans. Who suffers? The kids who are not allowed to have homes, loving parents, and the medical treatment most of them need.

Ukrainian gazillionaire who owns Roshen candy factories is active in Maidan and is running for president? Putin closes his factory in Russia. Who suffers? The Russian citizens who lost their jobs.

There are many more examples like this already documented, and, sadly, more to come. How many Russian citizens have to be punished before they realize what is going on?

People’s Republic of Idiots

So, the geniuses sent to Kharkiv to start a mess there knew the city so well that they first attacked the opera house, thinking it was the mayor’s building. When the stumbled upon the auditorium – oops! Not gonna find a mayor here, dudes.

The geniuses sent to Donetsk (who did manage to find the office they were looking for) took over the regional administration building Sunday night, and on Monday morning hastily held a “vote” declaring the establishment of the People’s Republic of Donetsk, and immediately asked for Russia to protect them. Obviously, this was not a spontaneous “uprising”, they not only had supplies ready (truck loads of tires were delivered, for example, to build barricades), they also had thought enough ahead they even had a special banner made for their new “republic”.

Monday was tense, I’ll admit that. The government didn’t appear to be moving quickly or effectively, but I think we’ve all lost perspective with such constant access to information (correct and incorrect).

In any case, by Tuesday morning, the Kharkiv dipsh*ts had been cleared out of the government building and were under arrest. The self-proclaimed Republic of Donetsk unproclaimed itself, due to lack of support from anyone else in Donetsk. Dipsh*ts didn’t bring enough people with them!

From EuromaidanPR:
Separatists canceled their decision to establish the Republic of Donetsk – Liga.Net – April 8, 2014, 11:55 Kyiv time
Donetsk citizens outraged by the fact that “hundred crazy people” took decision on behalf of more then one million city of Donetsk and four million Donetsk Region.

Separatists have canceled the decision to establish the Republic of Donetsk. This news was reported by Alexei Matsuka, page editor of News of Donbass in his Facebook account. People of Donetsk responded to the proclamation of the republic Donetsk with indignation. “In such megacity as Donetsk hundred abnormal people proclaimed Donetsk as republic. This is sort of joke ” – people of Donetsk write in social networks.

As a reminder. Separatists held talks with Deputy Prime Minister Vitaly Yarema this night under mediation of oligarch Rinat Akhmetov. Extremists promised the government to surrender their weapons. However, this the morning separatists declared that they wait for the assault from riot police and they are not going to disperse. They urge women to stay near the Donetsk Regional State Administration and become a human shield.

It’s not over, by any means. Separatists still have buildings in Donetsk and Luhansk, and tried to take buildings in Mykolayiv last night.

Meanwhile, in Russia, just looking like you might be thinking about protesting is enough to get you arrested.

The storm after the calm

It’s eerie that just a couple hours after I wrote yesterday’s post, Putin took his next step.

Putin clearly laid out his plans in late March, using ousted president Viktor Yanukovych to deliver his message to Ukrainians: “Demand a referendum on the status of each region within Ukraine”.

This is not going to be a “traditional” war, not even a “modern” war. Putin is waging his war on Ukraine one region at a time, using not a regular army of soldiers to invade, but using his “army” of paid provocateurs and bandits. Just as he almost never speaks himself to the public, famously giving one marathon press conference a year and instead delivering his messages via mouthpieces like Yanukovych or his more preferred frontman Dmitri Kiselev, he is dressing up his aggression against Ukraine in separatists’ clothes, bogus referendum to join Russia, and “pleas for help” from self-declared officials”. This was exactly the scenario he played out in Crimea, and now he’s doing it in eastern Ukraine.

Some articles I meant to share yesterday:

Follow the Money

Putin’s Brain: Alexander Dugin and the Philosophy Behind Putin’s Invasion of Crimea

The calm before the storm?

We continue to slowly come out of the fog that has enveloped us for so many months. Maybe it’s the sunshine, the warm temperatures, the flowers popping up and the first apricot tree to bloom on our street… but we feel a little bit better. Maybe it’s the not-so-terrible news we wake up to and go to bed thinking about – parliament is working, making progress on reforms; the police are working, making progress on investigating and arresting the snipers who murdered demonstrators on Maidan on those terrible days in February. There are still many, many questions to be answered, many issues to be dealt with, but we feel now a little bit of hope for the future.

We all still ache with sorrow about the occupation of Crimea, a physical pain from the amputation of a part of the body of the nation. We still watch the borders with Russia intensely, vigilantly. We still read the increasingly ridiculous and absurd Kremlin propaganda, ironically called the “news” in Russia, and we still work at spreading the truth.*

But we start to do “normal” things again. Dinner with friends whom we haven’t seen in months. We shared our Maidan stories and comforted each other, and actually talked a bit about other things, too. We went to a social event, the opening a new photo exhibition at the Fulbright Commission, about the Women of Maidan.



We went to a ceremony yesterday at the hospital behind our apartment building, the one that received hundreds of Maidan’s victims, the one I watched from my balcony on February 20, when I counted 45 ambulances bringing the wounded and dead, the victims of the Berkut snipers. I stopped counting at 45, but the ambulances kept coming all night. (Six weeks later, I still tense up and catch my breath when I hear the ambulance sirens approaching.) The ceremony was in honor of the hospital staff who saved hundreds of lives during Maidan, and a memorial was dedicated to them at the emergency entrance.

I asked Igor the other night if we were wrong to feel less afraid, to start to do “normal” things again, if it is maybe part of Putin’s strategy to let us feel calm long enough that we lose our vigilance, so he can attack when we no longer expect it. Igor explains it differently, he sees that Ukrainians understand the country is already at war, and we have already adapted to living in a new way. We aren’t less aware of the threats around us, we have incorporated them into our lives. We aren’t less vigilant, we are ready. Everything we do is enveloped by Maidan, it is who we are now, it is how we live now. We have learned how to be calm under threat, which is a very different kind of calm.

Prime Minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk was interviewed on the BBC’s HARDtalk, I highly suggest watching the clips, or better yet, get a British VPN and watch the full interview on the BBC’s iPlayer. (Unfortunately, the full interview is only available in the UK, but a VPN like Astrill is a nice work-around.) He says exactly what Igor has been saying, “It’s not just a matter of strength, it’s a matter of spirit.” This is what Putin underestimated about Ukrainians, and if he invades Ukraine from across another border, this is what will be his downfall. Ukrainians are NOT Russians, they do not respond to him or his style the way Russians do. As I wrote last month, Ukrainians will fight to obliteration before submitting again to rule from Moscow, I have no doubts about this.

What can the U.S. and the EU do? Well, John McCain just needs to shut the f*ck up, first of all. Ukraine is an industrial country that EXPORTS military equipment, including to Russia (although not anymore; Russia’s response, as always, is ironic and almost humorous – we didn’t want your stuff anyway!).

The U.S. shipment of MREs is actually extremely helpful, and is exactly the kind of useful support needed right now.

What REALLY can the U.S. and the EU do? Suck it up, and take some tough economic actions that are going to hurt you a little bit, too. Stop buying Russian gas and oil, and stop selling goods to Russia. It’s that simple, it’s that tough.

We’re not just asking you to make some sacrifices, trust me. The Ukrainian parliament passed a very tough austerity package last week, including deep cuts in government spending on itself (the hardest kind of cut for any politician, eh?). The price of gas is going to nearly double for most Ukrainians in the near future.

Rachel Maddow reports better than I can about the actions the U.S. can and should take (the first part is interesting, but if you want to get to the point, skip to 5:30).
http://player.theplatform.com/p/2E2eJC/EmbeddedOffSite?guid=n_maddow_4ships_140401

Some more good reading and watching:
Putin’s Patriotism is Phony, His Desperation is Real
The ideology of the EuroMaidan Revolution, by Serhiy Kvit, former president of Kyiv Mohyla Academy, Minister of Education since Feb. 27, was a Fulbright Scholar at Ohio University!

Ukraine – The Birth of a Nation: “historical documentary film in 4 parts about the history of Ukraine” (haven’t had a chance to watch all this yet, but am looking forward to it)

Jung & Naiv in Ukraine: incredible videos and interviews. I found a link to his Odesa visit on a blog I read, and discovered he has 20 videos on Ukraine and Maidan so far. Also VERY much looking forward to watching them all.

* I decided the “other world” Merkel said Putin lives in is called “Opposite World” – it’s so much easier to understand him once you realize what he and his puppets say is actually the opposite of what he thinks and intends to do. Read this article as if it’s in The Onion, as if every statement has the opposite meaning of the words used, and it’s not only much more real, it’s also kinda hilarious. (It also helps to understand that Yanukovych is just a ventriloquist’s puppet, there is absolutely no way Putin allows him to say or do anything publicly on his own.)

Webinar “Ukrainian Struggle Explained: The Maidan Revolution, Resistance to Military Intervention and Citizens’ Organizing”

Many thanks to my dear friend Madeleine for sharing the announcement for this webinar! An outstanding lineup of speakers.

“Ukrainian Struggle Explained: The Maidan Revolution, Resistance to Military Intervention and Citizens’ Organizing”
ICNC Live Webinar Discussion – open to the public
Wednesday, April 9, 2014 / 12:00pm – 1:45pm EST

An ICNC-moderated webinar discussion will bring together four Ukrainian guests with backgrounds in academia, journalism, activism, and policy to talk about the political conflict in Ukraine. A number of false narratives have emerged that branded the Maidan Revolution as violent, driven by radicals and external powers. After the invasion of Crimea and its annexation to Russia some commentators suggested that the outcome of the referendum reflected the preferences of the majority of the Crimean population and the political change represented by the annexation of Crimea to Russia was in fact engineered peacefully, which contrasted with the supposedly violent nature of the Maidan Revolution that brought down the Yanukovych regime.

This webinar will address the prevailing misconceptions that emerged around the conflict in Ukraine. It will discuss the origin, goals, strategies and tactics behind the Ukrainian Maidan movement, as well as its composition and its responses to the state-sponsored repression. Webinar discussants will talk about the role of a violent minority – a radical flank in the movement – and reflect on the impact of external actors in the Ukrainian struggle. How, and more importantly why was the Yanukovych regime ultimately brought down? In the final part of the conversation, the speakers will offer their views on the ongoing mobilization of the Ukrainian society against Russia’s annexation of Crimea, and against a possible Russian invasion of other parts of Ukraine, as well as civic organizing to support but also pressure the Ukrainian government to implement needed reforms.

Speakers
-Nataliya Gumenyuk, Ukrainian journalist, Co-Founder of Hromadske.TV
-Olga Onuch, Newton Fellow, University of Oxford / Research Fellow, Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute
-Dmytro Potekhin, Trainer and consultant in strategic planning and nonviolent resistance
-Olena Tregub, Policy expert of the Institute for Euro-Atlantic Cooperation and a writer for Kyiv Post